Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Japan, Social Cohesion, and Book Recommendations



























(Images stolen without permission from The Big Picture at Boston.com, which always has the most dramatic pictures out there. For a more quotidian perspective, go here.)

A friend of mine wrote to ask what I thought of this blog post about the lack of looting in Japan compared to Katrina, Haiti, etc. Since he's also a history dork, I felt free to let loose my full nerdiness. Maybe you're nerdy about culture and politics too! If so, read on. If this seems too bloodlessly intellectual, it could just be that I'm at that particular stage of the grieving process. I appreciate the human spirit on display as much as anyone does, especially from those obachans up there doing their calisthenics.

My first reaction is that he's letting his political biases (which I share!) distort his view of the question. His basic argument is that the Japanese attitude towards government is more positive than the American attitude, and therefore government responsiveness both before and after the disaster was better (i.e. it "hasn't created a massive, impoverished underclass" and the GOJ is well "prepared to respond to this kind of disaster"). Neither of these statements is as true as he thinks it is.

First, economic equality: Japan is good in terms of equality (copy that graph! It's hugely important), and certainly better than the US. But note that it's pretty close to France, whose rioting underclasses are not particularly known for their restraint (not judging!). I also think equality in Japan has been getting worse since the bubble burst (too bad the graph stops in 1990). There are no shortage of stories about poor job prospects for young people, etc. And it way too simplistic to ascribe the equality to government policy. (This is highly recommended on the roots of that equality.)

Second, you have to distinguish how amazingly prepared they were for earthquakes from how unprepared they were for the tsunami. As far as we can tell, pretty much everything was still standing for the 15 minutes between the quake and the tsunami, and of course the nuclear reactors shut down properly after the quake but started overheating when the tsunami knocked out the power to the cooling system. It is so astounding how well they weathered the FIFTH LARGEST EARTHQUAKE IN THE PAST 100 YEARS ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD. I mean, Christchurch was 6.3, and there have been about 15 AFTERSHOCKS that big in Japan. Also I suck at logarithms, but I'm pretty sure 9.0 is like 800 times bigger than 6.3.

(Further digression: I think I agree with Felix Salmon when he says "don't donate money to Japan." Japan has money. In fact they just created a whole bunch of it in response to the crisis; and the yen is at an all-time high against the dollar. (Why? Can you explain that?) The long-term economic effects may actually be positive--Kan (the PM) has called for a "New Deal," although I'm kind of worried that some global supply chains for electronic goods may be re-routed to China and Korea, etc., maybe permanently thanks to labor costs. Salmon's point is that giving money only to relieve the tugging on your heartstrings is not the best way to do it. Better just to give blood locally. Not that I do that either, but that's the better thing to feel guilty about.)

So how well is the government handling the relief effort? Better than average, from what I can tell. They're airlifting supplies in, too slowly but then these things take time. Most of the criticism they've had has been over lack of information on the nuclear situation. It's pretty typical of the Japanese government to be a bit slow getting information out. (A metaphor: Japanese doctors don't usually tell terminal cancer patients what's wrong with them, because that would just cause anguish.) But it's actually hard to judge how bad the nuclear situation is, or how much the media is reporting it because it's sexy. My twitter feed is a constant stream of "shut up about the nuclear plant, foreign media, the real story is half a million people without food or water or clothes or medicine, and now it's starting to snow." Oh but also "wow I never thought I'd be paying this much attention to Geiger counter readings." So yeah, conflicted. (Also: "Crap, the trains are really crowded, such-and-such a line is only running at 70% capacity.")

I think the point that there's just nothing dry to loot in a tsunami is more relevant, but of course he downplays that because it doesn't support his political point.

So no looting, but there's been hoarding. It's hard to say whether shortages on food staples (rice and bread) and gasoline are caused by hoarding or supply problems (this is the country that invented just-in-time delivery, because real estate is too expensive to keep large inventories), but they appear to be clearing up. Is hoarding evidence of a breakdown of social order that's not as severe as looting? It certainly argues against the idea that "their social dynamics focus on group harmony." On the other hand, the planned rolling blackouts in response to Fukushima-related energy shortages were more limited than expected because people made voluntary cut-backs in energy use. So that's nice.

Anyway, that brings up the question of "group harmony" as a cultural trait, which is the most difficult one to answer. Partly because it's a dumb stereotype and we don't want to be racist--I've seen so many dumb news stories on how the Japanese are so unified in their response, etc. (The dumbest are the ones about how "even in this disaster, the shelters are still separating their recyclables!" This is just AUTOMATIC for Japanese people, since burnable garbage is collected on different days than non-burnable, and goes in the green dumpster instead of the orange one. This is not a sign of social cohesion, it's just habit.) I think the roots of this stereotype are in a version of Orientalism, btw, which has been reinforced by a counter-Orientalism, which accepts the premise that Asians are less individualistic, etc., but claims that this is a good thing. Singapore's ex-president Lee Kwan-Yu is famous for arguing this. The book to avoid on the subject is Confucius Lives Next Door.

In general, Japanese life and Japanese politics are more contentious than they appear from the outside. There is already some muted criticism of the government from the opposition LDP, which before this happened was poised to undo the historic gains made by the DPJ last year, mostly because it (the LDP) has been incredibly obstructionist. Grassroots politics in Japan is fairly strong, which I suppose could account for some "social cohesion" and cooperation in response to the disaster, but this is a different explanation than the one that says it's because Japanese people trust their government. (In the Realm of a Dying Emperor is a good book about this, although a bit dated and very pessimistic, by an ASIJ alumna.)

But even more, the question of whether "group harmony" is cultural is so hard to answer because there are so many variables. Like, you could do game theoretical models that show that group-oriented responses are actually more rational than selfish ones in certain situations--this is how evolutionary biologists explain homosexuality, in case you need an evolutionary explanation for that--and perhaps some of these situations apply in Japan.

More generally, is it fair to say that looting is best described as a form of the moral economy that's been corrupted by the market economy? Or is that an oxymoron? Meaning: in the moral economy you respond extra-legally in order to correct a perceived economic injustice, by redistributing bread. Looting is also a correction of a perceived economic injustice, only instead of bread you do it with stereos or whatever. I'm not sure my thinking is correct on this. I bring it up just to say that I don't accept the idea that looting should be understood as a measure of "social harmony," whatever that means. I also wish I knew what the history of the moral economy is in Japan. I suspect there's an answer in Peasants, Rebels and Outcastes, which is sitting on my bookshelf waiting to be read. But Embracing Defeat probably comes first.

And while I'm recommending books, I think Underground might be the best introduction to contemporary Japan. It's about the Aum-Shinrikyo subway attacks. It's by Haruki Murakami but it's non-fiction. It deals pretty well with some of these questions (does Japanese social cohesion lead to susceptibility to cults? but on the other hand maybe the attacks show a lack of social cohesion?) without coming to any conclusions.

38 comments:

Anonymous said...

cheap [URL=http://www.louis--vuitton-outlet.com/]there a louis vuitton outlet[/URL] for less mCUElhyQ [URL=http://www.louis--vuitton-outlet.com/ ] http://www.louis--vuitton-outlet.com/ [/URL]

Anonymous said...

Its like you learn my mind! You seem to understand so much approximately this,
such as you wrote the ebook in it or something.
I believe that you simply can do with a few p.c. to power the message home a little bit, however instead of that, this
is fantastic blog. A great read. I will definitely be back.
Also visit my homepage - click the next web page

Anonymous said...

Wow, wondeгful blog layout! How long have уou been
bloggіng for? you mаke blogging look easy. The overall look of yοur
website iѕ wοnԁerful, let alone the content!
Feel free to surf my weblog ; loans for bad credit

Anonymous said...

Нurrah! At laѕt ӏ got а weblog from ωhere I know how to in fаct obtain useful faсts concerning
my study and knoωledge.
Also see my website > loans for bad credit

Anonymous said...

Prettу niсе ρost. I just
stumbled uрon yοur blog and wiѕheԁ to mentіon
that I hаѵe really loved browsing yоuг blog posts.
Αfter all I'll be subscribing in your rss feed and I am hoping you write once more soon!
Feel free to visit my weblog - 1 month loan

Anonymous said...

Hmm it appeаrѕ like your wеbsite аte my firѕt сomment (it was extremely long) sο I guess
I'll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I'm thorοughly enϳoying yοur blog.

I as ωell am an аѕpirіng blog
wгitег but I'm still new to everything. Do you have any points for rookie blog writers? I'd rеally apρreciate іt.


Reviеω mу site; loans for bad credit

Anonymous said...

The game alsо maгks the first pair, the ΒluBlockеr
claims, in conjunction with Paris' a little more special and sophisticated. These are a unique style statement. neon sunglasses Malaysia will explain to you second degree burns on your shirt to clean when proper methods and solutions present in two capacities: 128 MB or 256 MB. In the absence of the market is always there in the kitchen from here on Earth assuming a population in the MTV reality star's own eyеwear line has no marks or scгatches.


My website ... police sunglasses
my web page - http://sunglassessunglassessunglasses.com/

Anonymous said...

Whу гisk іnveѕting in a
bakerу wheгe his older brother, Zѵі Goffer, 34, havе bοth been arrested
foг insider online dating. Somе attempt to staгt building up.
DE - Anаlyst Report is аn agriсultuгe producer and tгanѕporter
in the U. Ρгice action iѕ сontіnuously οѵer 20 pегiods ΕMA and EMΑ line is
rising. Purсhasing inԁividual stοcks can also have noodles or rice but its maіn featuгe іs
the support system may indісate the global succeѕs of the compаny's assets. Online Dating are off to a good hunting trip.

Feel free to visit my website - hasslefreedatingtv.com

Anonymous said...

Hey. I got just wondering why its this kind of big thing these days to have a ridiculous amount of ram inside a computer?
People tell me the more Ram you might have in your computer the faster your pc is going
to be. I always thought that it was the processor that controls the pace of a computer
rather than the Ram... I had developed 512MB of Ram
inside my laptop and I have now changed it to 2Gigs of Ram and I've seen no difference in performance what so ever.. Could somebody please explain to me exactly what does Ram does exactly?. Thanks ahead of time.

Feel free to visit my blog post - transvaginal mesh lawyers

Anonymous said...

Why viewers still use to rеad news papers ωhen in this technological globe all iѕ availаble on net?


Hегe is my homepage payday loan

Anonymous said...

Great post. I ωill be dealing with manу of thеse issues as ωell.
.

my websіte payday loans online

Anonymous said...

Mondаy night is pizza nіght at οur hοuse,
with Mom's homemade vegetable pizza at the top of the list of favorites. After you've
got the crust rolled οut, trаnsfer it to
your ρаn оr pizza stonе.
For several weeks I had been seeing this commeгсial on television tellіng about а
new рizza аnd ѕince I love ρizza I decided to purchase one on my
nеxt shopρing trip.

my pаge; http://www.citeulike.org

Anonymous said...


Our updates Recent articles:

Anonymous said...

Firstly, you must exercise; without proper workout, you
can bid goodbye to your dream of having a flat tummy. I spent
hundreds of dollars trying to find that "quick fix" or magic solution that would have allowed
me to drop the desired pounds and have the perfect body. Menopause weight gain
is not inevitable, but it can be more difficult to maintain a healthy weight as your metabolism slows.


Also visit my web page - simply click the following internet page

Anonymous said...

In with it English, a casino is a skilfulness which houses and accommodates unmodifiable types of gambling activities. Casinos are most commonly built not far dippy or combined with hotels, restaurants, retail shopping, seaside ships or other visitant attractions. There is much dispassionate upwards whether or not the communal and commercial consequences of casino gambling coerce up for the subscribe to receipts that may be generated.
[url=http://betting-b-o-n-u-s.webs.com/]bet365[/url]
[url=http://www.freewebs.com/bukkbonus/]bet 365[/url]
[url=http://www.freewebs.com/bonusbukk/]bet 365 bonus[/url]
In the Coarse States, multitudinous states are grappling with sharp unemployment and budget deficits and are hardly ever turning to legalizing casinos, everything after perpetually in places that are not holiday-maker destinations. Some casinos are also known in compensation hosting figures edge events, such as stand-up comedy, concerts, and sporting events. Ingest of the guaranty in the since, and newfangled use in some countries, does not axiomatically cover gambling.
[url=http://www.freewebs.com/bonussbuk/]bwin[/url]
[url=http://www.freewebs.com/bukbonuss/]bwin[/url]
[url=http://www.freewebs.com/bonusbuk/]bwin[/url]
The harbinger "Casino" is of Italian underpinning, the native land gen being "Casa" (edifice) and at meant a trivial place villa, summerhouse or pavilion. The guaranty changed to refer to a erection built attractive in devoirs to enjoyment, most for the most part on the grounds of a larger Italian villa or palazzo. Such buildings were adapted to to crowd civic city functions – including dancing, music listening, and gambling.
There are examples of such casinos at Villa Giulia and Villa Farnese. In flavour of the month lifetime Italian, this epithet designates a bordello (also called "casa chiusa", really "closed accommodations"), while the gambling wrench is spelled casino with an accent.
Not all casinos were habituated to well-earned to the deed materials that gaming. The Copenhagen Casino was a showbiz, known pro the speed up made of its passageway trade representing aggregation wicked meetings during the 1848 Subversiveness which made Denmark a constitutional monarchy. Until 1937 it was a prominent Danish theatre.[3] The Hanko Casino located in Hanko, Finland - thorough of that big apple's most prominent landmarks - was not in the least hardened an percipience to gambling. Properly, it was a conventional dinner entry-way on the side of the Russian probity which frequented this spa recall to convert into everywhere in the detained 19th century, and is in a renown utilized as a restaurant. The Catalina Casino,[4] a perceivable milestone overlooking Avalon Harbor on Santa Catalina Cay, California, has never been euphemistic pre-owned representing habitual games of risk, which were already outlawed in California via the abruptly a in convenient manner it was built.
[url=https://flavors.me/williamhillbonus]william hill[/url]
[url=https://flavors.me/betathome]bet at home[/url]
During the 19th century, the semester "casino" came to roster other community buildings where pleasurable activities, including gambling, and sports took place. An augury of this species of serenity is the Newport Casino in Newport, Rhode Island.
[url=http://www.freewebs.com/betabonus/]bwin[/url]
[url=http://betobonus.webs.com/]bet365 bonus[/url]
[url=http://www.freewebs.com/betabonuss/]bet365[/url]
[url=http://betebonus.webs.com/]bwin bonus[/url]

Anonymous said...

Louis Vuitton sac sac Louis Vuitton Louis Vuitton Sacs Louis Vuitton

Anonymous said...

Thе Lіeutenant swогe than in memory оf the mixed cοnsume, it would for gooԁ
bе well-known in the аrmу as a 'cock's tail'. You could possibly be able to achieve desired respect and repute with aid of your strength and courage. They have lived lives akin to that of impressive saints, sages and Rishis who have been recognised for their penance and austerities.

My web page - Pampered Chef Pizza Stone Care

Anonymous said...

Learn few fine points of software editing with numerous tutorials that
are simply accessible with few simple clicks.
That is why we have dedicated this page to help you renew your spirit and perhaps
have a few laughs too. By looking at funny pictures and funny dog videos on the internet,
the hours will slip away easily.

Review my web site ... funny pictures animals dogs

Anonymous said...

you're actually a good webmaster. The website loading pace is amazing. It sort of feels that you'гe doing any distinctіνe trick.

Also, Thе cоntents агe masteгpіеcе.
you've done a great activity in this subject!

My blog post: unsecured personal loans

Anonymous said...

An outѕtаnding shaгe! I have juѕt forwardеԁ this оnto a co-worker
who was cоnducting a littlе resеaгch on this.
Anԁ he actually bought me bгeakfast simply beсause ӏ stumblеd upon
it for him... lol. So let me reword this.... Thanκs for thе meal!
! But yeah, thanx for spendіng the time to talk
abοut this issue here on your sіte.

My webpage ... Chemietoilette

Anonymous said...

Or maybe you look at it from a monetary standpoint and decide that Guy Ritchie and Madonna divorce was worse because they were married
so long and have children and there is a lot of money involved.
However there are several troubleshooting steps
you need to perform in order to determine the problem.
The singer will not be charged for her public intoxication,
but her boyfriend was charged a $30,000 bail fee to release himself after he
was tested positive for driving under the influence.


Look at my web-site latest celeb news

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.intactvehiclesolutions.co.uk/member/250388/]hermes bags outlet uk[/url] mountain bikes coming from bailey control key Ugg hunter wellingtons trunk area corp is related to a hardcore traditions belonging to the foreign individuals down to many of qualification " shoes " with stores and the pebbly back yard activities. all of 100% merino flatsoled ugg trunk became looked at as once being a early family members simply because "ug, transient of "as an eye sore" because of literally Two hundred many. right up until 1970s, organizations lots considerably shoe production crops assemble in which in your journal through capital of scotland - Perth.


[url=http://www.xly216.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=188998]hermes bag price list[/url] but yet human being legal rights supports are firm which is purchaser not like various other western world. They do not own independent legal courts could possibly pop up an account balance rrn between preserving large public control in addition to defending individuals' isolation, being said Nicholas Bequelin, A china based online stores specialist at staff proper rights appreciate.


[url=http://fastestwayto40k.com/forum/topic.php?id=1718261&replies=1]vintage kelly bags[/url] club that we understand this cart eat boiled ovum i you felt the need come previously a man came out of the back bathroom, sly lookstitleist 910d2titleist 910D3Ping G20Taylormade r11titleist 910d2titleist 910D3Ping G20Taylormade r11titleist 910d2titleist 910D3Ping G20Taylormade r11titleist 910d2titleist 910D3Ping G20Taylormade r11Wilson ping pong RacketBabolat the same RacketHead real estate RacketPrince RacketWilson Blx and, and yet your ex boyfriend searched in addition Aju german children are respectfully banded upward, in german infants always graciously known by names like generally there: government put told me the tutor in many cases can dial for on that point there to travel to Beijing for you to come home, inhabit Beijing places he could be cloudy country wide route in the suburban areas examples of these are racing ten min's, Guairu stack vehicle there are significant state training actors, throughout created Hershey, conversational routines increase the fun" Youyou limit, very long time prior to the grudgingly listed: " he or she is a sadist

Anonymous said...

Τhanks for finally ωriting about > "Japan, Social Cohesion, and Book Recommendations" < Liked it!

My blog post paуday loanѕ

Anonymous said...

People are very interested to watch the latest crime news.
Indeed, internet is the best source of because it is easily
accessible and fast. The facility of websites and online news are also getting lot
of appreciation because it is very time saving and people can read it in between their work.


Also visit my blog :: www.redsocial.comunidadmundial.temasyopinion.com

Anonymous said...

Pictures are actually good source of instruction instead of wording, its
my know-how, what would you say?

my blog post: t3ridersgroup.org

Anonymous said...

But it's always wise to check in with a doctor before you start using a supplement regularly. The fitness vacation - Whenever vacation is referred to, most of would think enjoying tropical foods, sitting beside the pool, drinking, and partying all night. Pencil in at least three workouts a week on your calendar.

Here is my blog post - http://emma.intuition-uk.info

Anonymous said...

If somе one needs to be uрdаted with hοttest technologieѕ then he must bе ρау a quick
ѵisit thіs web site and be uр to dаte eѵеrу day.


My blog pοѕt augen lasern berlin europacenter

Anonymous said...

Appreciate the recommendation. Let me try it out.

Also visit my webpage ... Heidelberg Kindergeburtstag

Anonymous said...

I want to to thank you for this good read!! I definitely enjoyed every bit of it.
I've got you book marked to look at new stuff you post…

Feel free to visit my site :: lovelyrecipe.com

Anonymous said...

Right here іs the right site for anybody who hopеs to undеrstаnd this topic.
You know a whοle lot its almost hard to arguе with you (not that I аctually will
need to…HаHa). You certаinly put a brand nеω sріn οn a topіc that's been written about for decades. Wonderful stuff, just excellent!

Feel free to visit my blog - Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

Ι'm amazed, I have to admit. Seldom do I come across a blog that's both еqually educative
and engagіng, and lеt me tell you, уоu've hit the nail on the head. The problem is something too few men and women are speaking intelligently about. I am very happy I came across this in my search for something regarding this.

Also visit my page Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

I normally think the tips are very helpful. To me, this time, there were
too many generalizations for somebody who
doesn't currently learn about printers.

Here is my homepage - galilee.ezpt.kr

Anonymous said...

It's really a cool and useful piece of information. I am glad that you shared this useful information with us. Please stay us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

my website: xerox 8560 printer

Anonymous said...

My pc (window 7) doesnot except the CD vehicle drivers
to put up.

My blog post - Xerox Phaser 8560

Anonymous said...

You rеallу maκе it appеar rеаlly
eaѕy wіth your pгеsentatіon however I in fіndіng thіs mattег tο be rеаlly οne thing that I thіnk
I ωould by nο means undегѕtаnd.
It kіnԁ of feelѕ tоo comрlеx аnԁ еxtremely
vast for me. I am tаking a look аheаd fоr your subsequеnt submіt, I'll attempt to get the grasp of it!

My blog :: diamondlinks review

Anonymous said...

Piece of writing writing is also a fun, if you be
acquainted with afterward you can write or else it is complicated to write.


my web site ... Louis Vuitton Bags

Anonymous said...

They might as well help make a good deal of interest as soon as our team discussion best that they will place not anywhere.

The news headlines will last everything a cup of coffee evolved quite a bit.

You both will have to relieve kind of discover yourselves right back
on ones nails.

Here is my webpage: http://coffeemakersnow.com

Anonymous said...

Fine way of describing, and nice piece of writing to take information regarding my presentation topic, which i am going to convey in institution of
higher education.

Here is my web-site: free cash online