Monday, April 21, 2008

No such thing as a guilty pleasure























No matter how disappointed many Hills fans might be at that New Yorker article (a pointless, lazy exercise in condescension that didn't even make a good faith effort to understand the show), it's not nearly as bad as this embarrassingly gushing review like this one of Gossip Girl. The conclusion to that article is that GG offers "profound social commentary." By which they mean: "The show mocks our superficial fantasies while satisfying them, allowing us to partake in the over-the-top pleasures of the irresponsible superrich without anxiety or guilt or moralizing." Um... let's just say that my definition of "profound" is very different from the one used by Ms. Pressler and Mr. Rovzar. "Social commentary," too. Or is that irony I smell? I can't quite tell, which in itself is a bad sign.

Actually I'm not sure Hills fans care that much about the New Yorker thing. The official MTV blog puts a positive spin on it, claiming that any mention in the New Yorker is an accomplishment, given the prestige of the magazine. They don't really need to take it seriously because the group of people who 1) read the New Yorker and 2) might possibly watch more than one episode of the show is approximately... me.











The two shows are actually pretty similar. Both are about the romantic lives of the hyperrich, centered on a Betty/Veronica rivalry; both include lots of references to text messaging and general new media connectivity as a nod to their interconnected audience. The difference between New York and LA is not that great. The real difference between the shows is that Gossip Girl allows for distanced, ironic viewing while The Hills does not. Kristen Bell's kitsch narration has a lot to do with this--because she doesn't appear in the show, the effect is to distance the viewer from the action and allow viewers to not feel guilty about indulging in their "superficial fantasies." Lauren Conrad's narration is limited to the "previouslies," and takes itself very seriously.

So we have people feeling superior to Gossip Girl but liking it anyway, and people feeling superior to The Hills and mocking it incessantly. None of this is surprising. But there's a way to feel superior to the show without mocking it or calling it a guilty pleasure--analyze it! Compare it to Antonioni, analyze narrative distance, name-drop Derrida and Barthes to show you've got more cultural capital than Heidi Montag. There's an obscurantist tendency in cultural studies to analyze the most disrespected aspects of popular culture; this may in the end be as condescending as simply dismissing them. To be honest, my appreciation of the show has very little to do with my feelings for its stars--Nancy Franklin is not far off when she says "I have yet to hear any character on the show say something interesting or funny." But the pleasures, for me anyway, lie elsewhere: I'm enough of a theory geek to actually enjoy all that cultural studies stuff.

17 comments:

eglenclub said...

mp4
divx
xvid
film izle
mp4 indir
2008

Anonymous said...

台灣的偶像劇越來越多人看,連韓國都瘋迷,台灣最近無敵珊寶妹的偶像劇很火紅,籃球火也展現出不錯的籃球絕技,帶點KUSO的內容的黑糖群俠傳也有對中國功夫的傳承,比笑話還好笑!台灣政治討論區中,總統府裡面的馬英九最受大家討論,因為浮動油價機制還沒結束,所以最近發現有不少人用免費空間網路打工的兼差抵抗現在的通膨,為了不讓電腦中木馬都會裝防木馬軟體以及防毒軟體,甚至還有人會去買大樂透微風論壇討論如何中獎,真的很誇張...

Anonymous said...

good post!!thanks




Anonymous said...

THANK YOU FOR YOUR BLOG DEAR

هيمة القلوب
منتدى هيمة القلوب
اسلاميات

willpoy said...

runescape money runescape gold runescape money buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape money runescape gold wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft Power Leveling Warcraft PowerLeveling buy runescape gold buy runescape money runescape itemsrunescape accounts runescape gp dofus kamas buy dofus kamas Guild Wars Gold buy Guild Wars Gold lotro gold buy lotro gold lotro gold buy lotro gold lotro gold buy lotro gold runescape money runescape power leveling runescape money runescape gold dofus kamas cheap runescape money cheap runescape gold Hellgate Palladium Hellgate London Palladium Hellgate money Tabula Rasa gold tabula rasa money Tabula Rasa Credit Tabula Rasa Credits Hellgate gold Hellgate London gold wow power leveling wow powerleveling Warcraft PowerLeveling Warcraft Power Leveling World of Warcraft PowerLeveling World of Warcraft Power Leveling runescape power leveling runescape powerleveling eve isk eve online isk eve isk eve online isk tibia gold Fiesta Silver Fiesta Gold
Age of Conan Gold
buy Age of Conan Gold
aoc gold

呼吸机
无创呼吸机
家用呼吸机
呼吸机
家用呼吸机
美国呼吸机
篮球培训
篮球培训班
篮球夏令营
china tour
beijing tour
beijing travel
china tour
tibet tour
tibet travel
computer monitoring software
employee monitoring

Anonymous said...

I love ur blog

runescape money said...

very great blog

runescape gold said...

very great blog

Anonymous said...

I love ur blog
very good!II like it

runescape money said...

very nice blog

Anonymous said...

I love ur blog
very good!II like it

tha said...

visit my blog

runescape money said...

I want have a link with your blog!

Anonymous said...

renewing alien resident card
health insurance for college
new jersey dental associaion
independent walking tours holland
shelter cove odenton md
student council historian slogan
anime students fucking
ssdi amount for dependent
christina pistel killed
special education teacher
free vip passes club
recent horror movies
deruta makers marks
pelvic exam video
diablo shadowmaster trainer
hoopz nude
homier shows
nude vietnamese models
atypical glandular cells
topless girls videos
ucla school of dentistry
car accident carver
wurtsboro ny car accident
beverly park estates denton
japanese commander apologises
hunting
download gratuito
isang kwentong
frasi
honduras mitos
last chaos
car accident
jannat song
big lycra
killer bee
tagalog
substitute
halimbawa ng
rainwater harvest
steinberg cubase
sears craftmans
what are
noli me
pokemon pearl
tulang padula
megarotic xhamster
car service
bugtong halimbawa
cole sprouse
misdemeanors classific
parabolang tagalog
mga halimbawa
fraternity circle
anabella saporiti
showdown
shaolin showdown
videos
md nautica
pagdating ng
hentai naruto
innocent little
tango
mexican white
virginia aguilar
james zota
spinal meningioma
nonprofit organazation
identification
santa margarita
toxic ex
u810
adult dirt
tivoli model
williamstown mass
wedding videograph
2008 mitsubishi
pictures
shypoke eggs
yhm sights
dextroamphetamine tabl
contact phentermine
missing student
kode
spinning star
pirate actor
dentists that
college grants
wolftrap arts
delorean motor
tensar polygrid
cernunnos
googal
denton
steve nash
calcul impots
did gwbushs
tablet
sentrol 1072
candle scented
2001 coleman

nike shoes said...

cool blog

面对面视频游戏 said...

You read these things, I think the mood has changed for the better!

Anonymous said...

lindos culos
savage 223
wallpaper famosas
medieval literature
xopenex better
clinica santa
pancake syrup
mefenamic
craftsman chainsaw
seasonale
gambar indonesia
booster elaborato
prozac during
radio mp3
wwe undertaker
sekandal dp
deos de
procto exam
diseno web
mace windu
who flies
free credits
naruto
cari gambar
sugar ray
compania seguro
canada online
copd advair
caligula walkthrough
amlodipine beslate
winstrol depot
endometriosis treatmen
premade div
pianura bergamasche
clomid clomiphene
pellicola finestra
mgaalamat
4 fuoco
index
mujeres divinas
any small
voli economici
lettera autocandidatur
juegos para
juejos juegos
kite
alphabetical list
cristiano ronaldo
g706 aia
flights from
ct statues
biliardo schiavon
tango shakira
brattleworks
troyes aviation
steroid cycle
enalapril maleate
phentermine lethal
evinrude
tie handkerchiefs
drums virtual
changing room
ontario baby
nudo amatoriale
cornacchini noleg
8os rock
teeny weeny
lawrence doll
salsiccia
super mario
merry christmas
insight car
push
travel nurse
start of
outlet guess
glucoband
hot bride
ayyappa malayalam
boxing day
fhoto sarahazhari
drink holders
educazione alla
new years
city contractor
anime manga
catholic bookstor
signal corp
photos
solaris sport
samashguitars ny
harold ziegler
vermont used
vita salute
ambien zolpidem
periodical histor
hitech eclipse
rental car
goverment crash
bd sisters
cheap internation
online medical